- The checkout insider
- Posts
- The Email Mistake That’s Costing You Thousands (And How to Fix It in 5 Minutes)
The Email Mistake That’s Costing You Thousands (And How to Fix It in 5 Minutes)
🔍 Quick Take: Most Ecommerce Brands Are Doing This Wrong
If you're sending abandoned cart emails and thinking, “Cool, we’re recovering lost revenue”, there’s a 90% chance you’re leaving serious money on the table.
💰 The Mistake: Your Abandoned Cart Flow Is Too Soft
Most brands send boring, generic reminders like:
“Hey, you left something behind! Here’s 10% off.”
The problem? It’s predictable. And predictable emails get ignored.
🔥 The Fix: Add Friction + Urgency
Steal this 3-step formula for higher abandoned cart recovery rates:
🔹 Email 1 (30 min later) – Emotion & FOMO
📩 Subject: Your cart is crying...
💡 People buy emotionally. Make them feel like they’re about to lose something great.
“We set your cart aside, but we can’t hold onto it forever. If you love it, grab it before it’s gone.”
🔹 Email 2 (18 hours later) – Social Proof
📩 Subject: Still thinking? Here’s what others say...
💡 Show a customer testimonial or UGC proving the product is amazing.
🔹 Email 3 (48 hours later) – Urgency & Scarcity
📩 Subject: Last chance – your cart disappears at midnight!
💡 Make it clear that the cart is expiring. Use countdown timers to drive action.
👉 Bonus Tip: A/B test "Your cart is expiring" vs. "Your cart is expiring (but we saved you 10%)" to see if urgency alone outperforms a discount. (Hint: It often does.)
⚡ Data-Backed Proof This Works
We ran this aggressive cart recovery strategy for a 7-figure Shopify brand. Results?
✅ 22% increase in recovered revenue
✅ 42% higher email open rates (thanks to subject line tweaks)
✅ 30% more conversions without increasing discounts
Takeaway: Fixing your abandoned cart flow is the fastest way to add thousands in revenue—without spending a cent more on ads.
📊 Insider Poll: What’s Your Biggest Email Marketing Challenge?
Hit reply & let us know:
A) Low open rates 📉
B) Cart abandonment 🤦♂️
C) Not enough repeat customers 🔄
D) Other (Tell us!)
We’ll break down the most voted challenge in next week’s issue. 🚀
🔗 Steal This Strategy for Your Brand
Need us to optimize your abandoned cart flow for you?
We do this all day, every day—so you don’t have to.
📅 Grab a quick call here → https://calendly.com/jpcharles/free-consultation-eb
Found this useful? Forward it to a friend who runs an ecommerce brand and should be in the know. 💡
See you next week,
— The Checkout Insider 🚀